BEATLES FOR SALE

Recorded from August 11, 1964 - till October 26, 1964

About the
viewpoints

1. No Reply

SOUND
B+

MELODY
B+

RHYTHM
B

ARRANGE
B+

IMPRESSION
B+

PROFUNDITY
B

ORIGINALITY
B+

PLAYABILITY
A+

The introduction that starts with vocal suddenly is fascinating, but also the cool passage in this song must be drums. A three-two bossanova style is played by the snare drum in the verse. I wonder why they performed such a rhythm style in this song. However, the snare drum is played at the usual beat of the 2nd and the 4th in the repeat of verse "I know that you saw me...". It is simply not extemporaneous, but is the rhythm with much consideration.

VERSE This happened once F6 - G6 - C - F6 - G6 - C6 - FM7 - Em - FM7 - Em - F6 - G6 - C6

16MEAS

CHORUS If I were you, I'd C - E7 - A - Dm - F - C - E7 - A - Dm - F - C

16MEAS

INTRO-VERSE-VERSE-CHORUS-VERSE-ENDING


2. I'm A Loser

SOUND
C+

MELODY
C+

RHYTHM
C+

ARRANGE
B-

IMPRESSION
C+

PROFUNDITY
C+

ORIGINALITY
B-

PLAYABILITY
A++

This song also begins with vocal, and has free-tempo. The acoustic guitar sound is featured in this whole song, so they say that it was due to the influence of Bob Delan. The very low pitch voices (low tone G at "crossed..." or "end...") are used, but those voices are not buried in backing, because John sings with his heavy voice. At the chorus, a four beat rhythm is played by the bass, and this sounds very cool. Paul sometimes plays a four beat on the bass unexpectedly, but his performance at this song is also in good taste.

VERSE Of all the love I have G - Dsus4 - Fadd9 - G - Dsus4 - Fadd9 - G - Dsus4 - Fadd9 - G - Dsus4 - Fadd9 - G

16MEAS

CHORUS I'm a loser, and I Am7 - D7 - Am7 - D7 - G - Em - Am7 - FM7 - D7

8MEAS

SOLO (Harmonica->Guitar) G - Dsus4 - Fadd9 - G - Dsus4 - Fadd9 - G - Am7 - D7 - Am7 - D7 - G - Em - Am7 - FM7 - D7

16MEAS

INTRO-VERSE-CHORUS-VERSE-CHORUS-SOLO-VERSE-CHORUS-ENDING


3. Baby's In Black

SOUND
B-

MELODY
B-

RHYTHM
B-

ARRANGE
B-

IMPRESSION
B

PROFUNDITY
B-

ORIGINALITY
B

PLAYABILITY
A++

This tune has a 12/8 time signature. The slow and triplet rhythm gives us freshness and peace of mind because the duet by Paul and John is perfect harmony. The guitar rif or solo that are played occasionally prevent monotony, and are as spice factor. In the latter half of song, at "She thinks of him...", the performance turns into only drums but Ringo plays kick drum with eighth note.

VERSE Oh, dear what I do A - E7 - D - E7 - A - D - E7 - A

3MEAS

VERSE2 She thinks of him A - A7 - D - A - E7 - A

4MEAS

CHORUS Oh, How long will F#m - B - D - E7

2MEAS

SOLO (Guitar) A - E7 - D - E7 - A

3MEAS

INTRO-VERSE-VERSE2-VERSE-VERSE2-CHORUS-VERSE-SOLO-CHORUS-VERSE-VERSE2-VERSE-ENDING


4. Rock And Roll Music

SOUND
C+

MELODY
C+

RHYTHM
C+

ARRANGE
C+

IMPRESSION
B-

PROFUNDITY
C+

ORIGINALITY
C+

PLAYABILITY
A++

Composed by Chuck Berry. This song has little introduction, solo, or ending, so John sings all the time without rest. Since this song is typical rock 'n' roll, the chord progression or melody is simple but a triplet rhythm is used in the ending. It gets into full swing and prevents a monotony of rhythm. I think that the reverb effect for vocal may be too wet.

VERSE Rock and roll music A - D7 - A - E7 - A - E7 - A

14MEAS

CHORUS I got no kick, kick E7 - A - D - E7

8MEAS

INTRO-VERSE-CHORUS-VERSE-CHORUS-VERSE-CHORUS-VERSE-CHORUS-VERSE-ENDING


5. I'll Follow The Sun

SOUND
B-

MELODY
B+

RHYTHM
C+

ARRANGE
A-

IMPRESSION
B+

PROFUNDITY
B

ORIGINALITY
B+

PLAYABILITY
A+

I was astonished by the chord progression at the beginning of vocal. Since the key on this song is C major, the progression such as "G7->F7->C" is converse pattern that progresses from dominant to sub-dominant. Moreover, The note Eb the 7th tone of F7 is used at "you'll" in "you'll look". And that note goes up half-tone from note D at "One" in the "One day...", so it forms very unique melody.At the chorus, the sub dominant chord is used, that is the most advanced arrangement in that time. The guitar solo seems to be weak but may be suitable from the image of this song.

VERSE One day, you'll look G7 - F7 - C - D7 - C - Em - D7 - G7 - C - F - C [- C7]*

8MEAS

CHORUS And now the time Dm - Fm6 - C - C7 - Dm - Fm6 - C - Dm

8MEAS

SOLO (Guitar->Vocal) G7 - F7 - C - D7 - C - Em - D7 - G7 - C - F - C - C7

8MEAS

INTRO-VERSE-VERSE*-CHORUS-VERSE-SOLO-CHORUS-VERSE-ENDING


6. Mr. Moonlight

SOUND
B

MELODY
B-

RHYTHM
C+

ARRANGE
B-

IMPRESSION
B+

PROFUNDITY
B-

ORIGINALITY
B-

PLAYABILITY
A++

Composed by Johnson in 1962. There are no unique points in particular, and the drum performance is not clear. Ringo may play the conga, but I wonder what the significance of the accent sound with a bang in whole song is. So he does not play only beat by drum set but also percussion mainly. And you can find that they are particular about their music from many such rhythm arrangement.

VERSE You came to me F# - B - F# - Ebm - B - F#

16MEAS

CHORUS And now she is B - F# - Eb7 - Ab7 - F#

8MEAS

VERSE2 Mr. Moonlight, F# - B - F# - Eb7 - Ab7 - F#

16MEAS

SOLO (Organ->Vocal) F# - B - F# - Eb7 - Ab7 - F#

8MEAS

INTRO-VERSE-CHORUS-VERSE2-SOLO-VERSE2-ENDING


7. Kansas City - Hey, Hey, Hey, Hey

SOUND
B-

MELODY
B-

RHYTHM
B-

ARRANGE
C+

IMPRESSION
B

PROFUNDITY
C+

ORIGINALITY
B-

PLAYABILITY
A++

The song that Hey-hey-hey-hey by Little Richard joins K.C Loving by Little Willy Littlefield is the original song. It is unique that the chord progression in the introduction is G->C6->G->D7, but after that it has typical shuffle blues progression. The well-modulated high tone by Paul is impressive, and the backing vocal harmony that takes turns singing in the latter half is also cool. It may be liven up if you perform this song. However, you may get tired out because you have to play the piano with triplet eighth note hard from beginning to end.

VERSE I'm goin' to Kansas G - C7 - G - D7 - C7 - G

12MEAS

CHORUS Hey hey hey hey, G - C7 - G - D7 - C7 - G

12MEAS

SOLO (Guitar) G - C7 - G - D7 - C7 - G

12MEAS

INTRO-VERSE-VERSE-SOLO-CHORUS-CHORUS-ENDING


8. Eight Day's A Week

SOUND
B-

MELODY
B-

RHYTHM
B-

ARRANGE
B-

IMPRESSION
A

PROFUNDITY
C+

ORIGINALITY
B-

PLAYABILITY
A++

The atmosphere in this song is also mysterious. It is not so hard as rock but is not like country though the acoustic guitar is featured. The rhythm pattern is shuffle just like All My Loving, and the bass pattern is the four beat. To compose such a song, it seems that they try to build up their new music style by mixing so many taste of music.

VERSE Ooh I need your D - E7 - G - D - E7 - G - D - E7 - G - E7 - G - D - E7 - G - D

16MEAS

CHORUS Eight days a week A - Bm - E7 - G - A7

8MEAS

INTRO-VERSE-VERSE-CHORUS-VERSE-CHORUS-VERSE-ENDING


9. Words Of Love

SOUND
C+

MELODY
C+

RHYTHM
C+

ARRANGE
B-

IMPRESSION
B-

PROFUNDITY
C+

ORIGINALITY
C+

PLAYABILITY
A++

Composed by Holly. The dazzling guitar sound is the introduction is characteristic. Because of the cover song, this song gives us different impression from ordinary Beatles melody. So many factors such as the vocal line with low tones, repeat of simple chord progression A->D->E7, and quiet drums, are heard in this song. They do not heard much in their other songs. It seems that they try to increase their sound variation by having a mind to borrow such a song. BTW, I wonder that why they use the hand claps from beginning to end, so once you noticed that, it may be offensive to the ear.

VERSE Hold me close and A - D - E7 - A - D - E7 - A - D - E7 - A - D - E7

8MEAS

VERSE2 Words of love you A - D - E7 - A - D - E7 - A - D - E7 - A - D - E7

8MEAS

SOLO (Guitar) A - D - E7 - A - D - E7 - A - D - E7 - A - D - E7 - A - D - E7 - A - D - E7 - A - D - E7 - A - D - E7

16MEAS

INTRO-VERSE-VERSE2-VERSE-VERSE2-SOLO-VERSE-VERSE2-ENDING


10. Honey Don't

SOUND
C+

MELODY
C+

RHYTHM
C

ARRANGE
C+

IMPRESSION
C

PROFUNDITY
C

ORIGINALITY
C

PLAYABILITY
A++

Composed by Perkins. Ringo takes main vocal after long interval. The chord progression is blues style in basic, but the major third progression such as E->C is used in the verse or solo, it is conspicuous among the blues music. It seems that the performance is not so complex, but the four beat bass line with solid tone is impressive. Ringo sometimes sings this song halfway, but his vocal with ad-lib is very cool.

VERSE Well how come you E - C - E - C - E

12MEAS

CHORUS Honey don't well E - A - E - G - A - E

12MEAS

SOLO (Guitar) E - C - E - C - E - A - E - G - A - E

20MEAS

INTRO-VERSE-CHORUS-VERSE-CHORUS-SOLO-VERSE-CHORUS-SOLO-ENDING


11. Every Little Things

SOUND
B-

MELODY
B-

RHYTHM
B-

ARRANGE
B-

IMPRESSION
C+

PROFUNDITY
C+

ORIGINALITY
B-

PLAYABILITY
A+

The introduction is magical. Maybe I think that the verse is used as the introduction, but it may have shuffle rhythm. This introduction is played by the guitar as if it is nothing difficult, but it is difficult to play this actually because it has special feeling of rhythm and delicate rest before vocal begins. After the verse, the 12 strings guitar is featured, and it is not so loud. However, Ringo plays the drums with elaborate patterns. He plays only kick drum in the verse, after that the snare drum sound is getting to increase, finally in the chorus, he plays the kick drum with eighth note. Moreover, the most fascinating point is the timpani played once in a while. I wonder this might be over-dubbed by Ringo.

VERSE When I'm walking A - D - E - A - G - D - Bm - Bm7 - E7 - A - D - E - A - G - D - Bm - Bm7 - E7

12MEAS

CHORUS Every little things A - G - A - G - A

8MEAS

SOLO (Guitar) A - D - E - A - G - D - Bm - Bm7 - E7

6MEAS

INTRO-VERSE-CHORUS-VERSE-CHORUS-SOLO-CHORUS-ENDING


12. I Don't Want To Spoil The Party

SOUND
B-

MELODY
C+

RHYTHM
C+

ARRANGE
B-

IMPRESSION
B-

PROFUNDITY
C+

ORIGINALITY
B-

PLAYABILITY
A+

This song is one of the country music. The vocal is duet by Paul and John from beginning to end except a part of verse "There's nothing for me...". However, their harmony does not have simple 3rd or 5th interval, but has opened voicing just like in the There's A Place. The guitar solo is a rhythmic phrase with middle tone, it is not loud but feels not to break the atmosphere of country.

VERSE I don't want to G - D7 - Em - B7- Am7- D - G - Fadd9 - G

16MEAS

CHORUS Though tonight G - Em7 - A7 - C - D7 - G - Em7 - A7 - C - D7

12MEAS

SOLO (Guitar) G - D7 - Em - B7- Am7- D - G - Fadd9 - G

16MEAS

INTRO-VERSE-VERSE-CHORUS-VERSE-SOLO-CHORUS-VERSE-ENDING


13. What You're Doing

SOUND
C+

MELODY
B-

RHYTHM
C+

ARRANGE
B

IMPRESSION
B-

PROFUNDITY
C+

ORIGINALITY
B-

PLAYABILITY
A++

It is unique for them because this song starts with four measures introduction of drums. It is impressive that George repeats rif with his 12 strings guitar, and this style is also used in Ticket To Ride. But, I think that the solo is not so cool, because the drums pattern in the introduction or ending is very fine. The timpani is also used just like Every Little Things.

VERSE Look what you're D - G - D - G - Bm - G - D - G

8MEAS

CHORUS I've been waiting G - Bm - G - Bm - E - A

8MEAS

SOLO (Guitar) D - G7 - D - G7 - D - G7

8MEAS

INTRO-VERSE-VERSE-CHORUS-VERSE-SOLO-CHORUS-VERSE-ENDING


14. Everybody's Trying To Be My Baby

SOUND
C+

MELODY
C+

RHYTHM
B-

ARRANGE
C+

IMPRESSION
C+

PROFUNDITY
C

ORIGINALITY
C

PLAYABILITY
A++

Composed by Perkins in 1958. It is typical rockabilly and is hard to say that this song is so unique. I wonder why they has recorded such a uncool song at the last of this album. George takes main vocal and gives us nice atmosphere, but a echo effect may be slightly too wet.

VERSE Well they took E - A7 - E - B7 - A7 - E

12MEAS

SOLO (Guitar) E - A7 - E - B7 - A7 - E

12MEAS

VERSE-VERSE-SOLO-VERSE-SOLO-SOLO-VERSE-VERSE-ENDING


- PLEASE PLEASE ME - WITH THE BEATLES - A HARD DAY'S NIGHT - BEATLES FOR SALE - HELP! - RUBBER SOUL -
- REVOLVER - SGT. PEPPER'S LONELY HEARTS CLUB BAND - MAGICAL MYSTERY TOUR - THE BEATLES (1/2) -
- THE BEATLES (2/2) - YELLOW SUBMARINE - ABBEY ROAD - LET IT BE - [TOP PAGE] -